Name: Bella Mia Cafe - Restaurant
Address: 134 W Main St, Bay Shore, New York, US

◐

Non-Dedicated

Community

Not yet confirmed by members.

Been here? Confirm or correct

Not medical advice. Always independently confirm preparation practices.

ⓘ How assessment works

Something look wrong? Sign in to report it

Reported by diners

No reports yet — we can help you know what to ask.

User-submitted data, not medical advice. Always independently confirm preparation practices.

Address

134 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Website

https://www.bellamiacafe.com/

Services

Takeout · Delivery · Kid friendly

What we've seen

Public reviews and restaurant replies · not verified

Bella Mia Cafe - Restaurant has a steady paper trail of diner reviews in Bay Shore. The setting gets its own mentions: a location in the middle of town and an inviting room. Practical notes from diners: a date-night crowd, a takeout habit among regulars and a dinner rush. Diners have confirmed gluten free versions of the arancini and ice cream.

Diners mention gluten-free arancini and ice cream.

arancini2ice cream2

Gluten-free comes up around dessert.

dessert2

Gluten-free comes up in 4 observed reviews; 4 diners in the past year.

Latest gluten-free signal: 2026-09