Dedicated Gluten-Free

GFMapper's Assessment

  • Sources checked by staff · Jul 2026

Community

Not yet confirmed by members.

Been here? Confirm or correct

Not medical advice. Always independently confirm preparation practices.

ⓘ How assessment works

Something look wrong? Sign in to report it

Reported by diners

Claim

User-submitted data, not medical advice. Always independently confirm preparation practices.

Address

1236 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028

Menu

Last checked 6/20/2026

Login to view full menu

Vanilla Sprinkle Cake

Layer Cakes

vanilla layers with vanilla chiffon filling and frosting covered in multicolored nonpareils Dress up your cake with either Frosting Flowers or one of our Sweet Little Additions! If you’re ordering Flowers or a Sweet Little Addition and colors are offered, please let us know in the box below which color you would like. Please note that we're unable to pipe anything in gold, silver, or any other metallic colors.box which color you would like. For additional customizations, special instructions, questions, or concerns, please email custom@btwbakery.com .

50

Chocolate Truffle Torte

Specialty Cakes

rich and truffle-like in texture – made with Belgian chocolate serves eight to ten

45

Almond Spiral (2)

Mini Cakes

with a delicate crumb and a light orange glaze

14

Carrot Cupcake (6)

Cupcakes

carrot cupcake with vanilla chiffon frosting

33

Fudge Brownie Cookies - bag of 6

Cookie Bags

a flourless crispy-chewy-chocolatey treat

15

Menu information comes from publicly-available menu data. Always confirm current ingredients, preparation details, and pricing with the staff.

Around the web

Public reviews and restaurant replies · not verified

Diners in Manhattan keep writing about By the Way Bakery. The kitchen is dedicated gluten-free, and everything served here is gluten free. Practical notes from diners: custom and advance orders, limited seating and birthday and celebration bookings. The dishes people keep coming back to: cake, brownies and cookies.

Diners mention gluten-free cake, brownies, cookies, muffins, pie and whoopie pies.

cake14brownies3cookies3muffins3pie3whoopie pies3+2 more

Diners also mention dairy free and vegan.

dairy free11vegan3

Gluten-free comes up around dessert.

dessert4

Gluten-free comes up in 20 observed reviews; 7 diners in the past year.

Latest gluten-free signal: 2026-06

Popular Tags

BakeryCasualCelebrationsDeliveryGroupsKid FriendlyPet FriendlyQuietTakeoutVeganVegetarian

Featured in

More gluten-free spots in New York

See all 570 gluten-free restaurants in New York

Own this restaurant? Add a GFMapper badge to your website